So, you’re thinking about buying a vacation rental as your first real estate investment. Maybe you’re lured by the idea of sipping coffee on the porch of your own mountain cabin or hosting out-of-towners in a beachside bungalow that mostly pays for itself. But before the vision board gets too dreamy, let’s bring it back to earth. There’s real money to be made in short-term rentals—if you approach it like a business, not a fantasy.
Start Where You Know the Terrain
You don’t have to own property in some exotic, far-off destination to make a short-term rental work. In fact, it’s usually smarter to invest somewhere you already know well—maybe a lakeside town you visited every summer growing up, or that quaint mountain village just two hours from your city apartment. Familiarity isn’t just comforting; it’s strategic. You’ll have an instinct for the local vibe, the seasonal flow of visitors, and what kinds of places travelers crave, whether it’s a cozy A-frame or a two-bedroom with strong Wi-Fi and blackout curtains.
Don’t Just Buy a House—Buy an Experience
When people book a vacation rental, they’re not just looking for shelter—they want a certain kind of escape. So, your job as an investor isn’t just to purchase a property. It’s to curate an experience that stands out in a sea of options. That might mean leaning into the mid-century vibe of a Palm Springs condo or embracing the rustic warmth of a log cabin in Vermont. Design choices matter here—not in a luxury-for-luxury’s-sake way, but in a way that makes your listing feel intentional and atmospheric. If people feel something when they walk in, they’re more likely to book again—or tell their friends.
Keep the Paper Trail Digital
In the vacation rental game, organization isn’t just helpful—it’s essential. From contracts and permits to receipts and tax records, having your documents in one easily searchable place can save you time and headaches down the road. With a mobile scanning app, you can quickly and easily capture any document or image from your device’s camera and convert it into a PDF. Embracing free scanner app technology ensures your records are always accessible, backed up, and ready when the accountant—or a last-minute guest inquiry—comes calling.
Run the Numbers Without Emotion
The most common mistake first-timers make? They fall in love with the property. And love clouds judgment. What you want is a vacation rental that can carry itself financially, not just one that looks good in photos. So before you close, do the boring math: look at average nightly rates in the area, occupancy trends across seasons, local regulations, and ongoing expenses like property management and cleaning fees. If the numbers work when you assume a conservative occupancy rate—say, 60%—you’re on safer ground. If you’re banking on 90% to stay afloat, you’re walking on a tightrope.
Fix What’s Broken Before Guests Notice
It might be tempting to list your property as soon as the keys hit your hand, but jumping the gun without addressing repairs is a surefire way to tank your ratings before you even get started. Before renting out your property, it’s crucial to repair any visible damage such as dents, cracks, or holes on the walls, and investigate hidden issues like potential water leaks behind appliances. First impressions carry weight, and even small defects can make guests question the overall upkeep of the home.
Get Comfortable Being a Host (Even if You’re Not On Site)
You don’t need to greet guests at the door or leave handwritten notes on the counter (though some hosts swear by that). But you do need a system that makes guests feel welcomed, supported, and clear on what to expect. Whether you manage it yourself or hire a property manager, the tone is set by you. Think smart locks, clear check-in instructions, quick replies to questions, and thoughtful touches that make people feel like they’re not just another booking. Remember: in this business, five stars are worth more than square footage.
Play by the Rules—Because They Change Often
Short-term rental laws are in flux, especially in popular tourist areas. One minute you’re raking in bookings, the next you’re hit with new restrictions or licensing fees you didn’t see coming. That’s why it’s crucial to understand the regulatory landscape before you buy—and to keep tabs on local politics afterward. Talk to other hosts, attend community meetings if you can, and be proactive about compliance. You don’t want to be the investor who gets shut down a year in because they didn’t file the right paperwork or missed a rule buried in municipal code.
Expect Seasonality—and Use It to Your Advantage
Vacation rentals aren’t like long-term tenants. There will be busy seasons and slower ones, and part of your strategy should be planning for that ebb and flow. The good news? Those lulls are golden opportunities. Use downtime to deep clean, refresh decor, update photos, or test dynamic pricing tools. Maybe even block off a few days for your own use—yes, one of the best perks of this investment is that you can occasionally enjoy it too. Just don’t let personal use eat into your prime revenue windows.
Think Beyond Airbnb and Build a Brand
Platforms like Airbnb and Vrbo are great for visibility, but they also control the relationship with your guests. If you’re serious about turning this into a long-term play, think about how you can build your own direct booking channel over time. That might mean setting up a simple website, collecting guest emails for future stays, or even starting an Instagram account that shows off your place’s personality. The goal? Create repeat customers who feel connected to your property, not just the platform they booked through. Investing in a vacation rental can absolutely help you build wealth—but it won’t happen overnight. Like any good investment, it takes planning, patience, and a willingness to learn as you go. You’re not just buying a second home; you’re starting a small business rooted in hospitality. If you treat it that way—if you show up with thoughtfulness, do the unsexy math, and adapt as you learn—you’ll find that it can be both personally rewarding and financially smart. Just don’t forget to enjoy the porch view every once in a while. After all, that’s what this is all about, isn’t it?
—Written by guest contributor Karyn Winrich
Copyright 2025 The Western Connect. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.